Liability for lost container on CFR sale

Home Forums Shipping and Freight Questions and Answers Liability for lost container on CFR sale

This topic contains 0 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by  hayshipper 4 weeks ago.

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #94942

    hayshipper
    Participant

    A company I know ships containers regularly and customers prepay against document copies by TT so shipper receives payment shortly after vessel sails and buyers have orignal documents before shipments arrive. This is standard in my industry. All CNF (CFR) deals. Recently five containers (a whole booking) were lost at see. For sake of simplicity just assume they fell off the ship or got abducted by alians.The expoter is not planning to return the payment siting that “In CFR deals, liability falls on the BUYER/IMPORTER as soon as the containers are loaded on to the vessel”. The buyer/importer says that in past lost cargo experiences the shippers have always refunded them the entire invoice which they had paid.
    QUESTION: In a CFR/CNF/C&F deal, is the shipper liable to ensure that the containers/product are physically delivered to the buyer’s port or only responsible to get the container on the vessel? Does liability fall to the importer after the vessel sails because they are to be the insurers in CFR deals? Is the shipper legally bound to refund payment? I can’t find the “legal” answer on line.
    Note: After the above shipper refused to refund payment, the buyer asked for 50% which was also refused. Is it possible that other shippers refunded the payments out of goodness, in order to keep the customer or is that the law or commonly accepted practice? I am being asked to make a judgement on this issue and need present the solid legal position.

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Share